
A week after California's board moved to tighten opt-out signal rules, it showed what enforcement of the existing ones looks like. Elsewhere, more states piled onto a health-data advertising case, and Brussels put its long-awaited consumer fairness package on the table. Here's what mattered.
Enforcement
The CalPrivacy board fined Federal Express $2.975 million↗ on November 10 for CCPA violations tied to online tracking. The agency's Enforcement Division alleged that FedEx falsely stated it did not sell or share personal information while participating in cross-context behavioral advertising, that it failed to honor opt-out preference signals, that its webform for CCPA requests didn't apply to online tracking technologies, and that the cookie controls meant to address tracking didn't work properly. Beyond the fine, the decision imposes specific operating requirements: a quarterly inventory of online tracking technologies with a review before any new one is added, configuration checks so contract instructions are followed, quarterly testing of opt-out compliance and of the methods for submitting CCPA requests, a working "Do Not Sell or Share" or "Your Privacy Choices" link, and cookie notices that explain how the control applies to sales and sharing and link to where consumers exercise the choice. CalPrivacy also stressed that the case involved a business-to-business setting, and that businesses should assess whether their B2B operations respect individuals' privacy rights. The lesson is that regulators are specifying a testing cadence, not just a policy: if your opt-out only works on paper, expect to be told how often to prove otherwise.
The FTC added five states to its lawsuit against Hims & Hers↗ on November 10, filing an amended complaint that brings in Arizona, Florida, Nebraska, Ohio, and Wisconsin alongside Utah and California (through Los Angeles County Counsel). The original complaint, filed in July, alleges the telehealth provider told consumers their health information stayed private while sharing it with Meta, Snap, and other third-party advertising platforms, and that it didn't clearly disclose near-immediate charging after an intake form and made cancellation hard. The amended complaint adds claims under the five new states' consumer protection laws, in addition to the FTC Act, the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act, and California and Utah law. These are allegations, and the case will be decided by the court in the Northern District of California. For anyone running advertising pixels on pages that touch health information, the case is a reminder that a privacy promise on the site is what regulators will compare your tracking against.
In Italy, the Garante fined Wind Tre €1.7 million↗ over two breaches notified in February 2025, a decision dated May 14 that the EDPB published November 10. Attackers posing as technical support persuaded staff at two retail outlets to grant remote access, then reached data on more than 365,000 customers, including payment details for 41,359 of them. The regulator found weak management of digital certificates, private keys, and access credentials in the sales network, inadequate security controls on certain APIs that allowed mass data extraction, and security assessments that missed detectable vulnerabilities. Wind Tre must also secure its certificates in encrypted repositories or key management systems and strengthen its other controls.
New and Pending Legislation
On November 11 the European Commission proposed the Digital Fairness Act. According to Covington's analysis↗, it is one of three parts of a consumer package, alongside a revised Consumer Protection Cooperation Regulation and a Simplification Directive, and it would replace the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive with a directly applicable regulation. The proposal would ban dark patterns, including false scarcity claims and pre-selected paid extras, and require clear labeling of influencer content. It would bar profiling-based advertising aimed at known minors or based on sensitive data, and let adults switch off features such as autoplay, endless feeds, and streaks. It also covers free trials and automatic renewals, requires an online cancellation function and access to a human customer-service contact, and sets rules for AI shopping agents that conclude contracts on a consumer's behalf. Email and SMS marketing would still need prior consent, with an existing-customer exception for email.
On enforcement, Covington reports that the Commission could directly enforce widespread EU-wide infringements with fines of up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover, while certain widespread national infringements keep a minimum fine of 4% of annual turnover; IAPP's account of the same proposal describes the cap in terms of global profits, so check the text. If adopted, the DFA and revised cooperation regulation would apply 12 months after entering into force. IAPP reports↗ that industry groups led by IAB Europe are objecting to new opt-out requirements for personalized advertising, which they say could worsen "cookie fatigue." Neither source gives an adoption timeline, and the proposal now goes to the Parliament and Council.
Guidance and Rulemaking
California's privacy agency began formal rulemaking↗ on November 13 to implement the Delete Act's requirement that data brokers undergo an independent third-party audit every three years starting January 1, 2028. The proposed regulations set the timing, scope, auditor qualifications and independence, required evidence, and report contents, and also update the rules on data broker registration and DROP access and processing. Written comments are due by 5 p.m. Pacific on January 6, 2027, when a public hearing will also be held.
The EDPB's November plenary produced three items. It adopted a statement on the first review of the Republic of Korea's adequacy decision↗, welcoming Korean amendments that include a general right to withdraw consent and a right to refuse or seek an explanation of significant automated decisions, and it finalized its recommendations on processor binding corporate rules, which existing holders must meet during the application process or by their 2028 annual update. It also picked the topic for its sixth coordinated enforcement action: automated decision-making, including AI-driven systems, in recruitment, focused on the right not to be subject to solely automated decisions and the related right of access in the use of automated candidate screening tools. Data protection authorities will sign up voluntarily in the coming weeks, and the action launches during 2027. Separately, the Board issued a statement on onward transfers↗, recognizing that the Council of Europe's and the Ibero-American Data Protection Network's model clauses may also be used for onward transfers of data received under the EU standard contractual clauses, under the conditions in the Commission's FAQs.
The Takeaway
The consistent message is that privacy controls are now being tested, not just documented. FedEx was fined for opt-out and cookie controls that didn't work, Hims & Hers is accused of tracking that contradicted its privacy promises, and California's next audit rules would make independent verification routine for data brokers. The practical to-do list is concrete: test every opt-out and request path on a schedule and keep the records, check whether advertising pixels fire on pages tied to health or other sensitive information, review dark patterns, auto-renewal flows, and cancellation paths against the Digital Fairness Act proposal even though it is more than a year from applying, and put the January 6, 2027 California comment deadline on the calendar if you are or work with a data broker.