CookieYes is the budget banner leader — cheap, fast to install, and fine for a small site. Here's how PieEye compares for eCommerce brands that need DSR automation and data mapping, not just a banner.
CookieYes is genuinely one of the cheapest, easiest banner installs anywhere — its free plan is real, and its per-domain pricing tops out at $55/month for unlimited pageviews. The catch is a pageview cliff on the free plan (the banner stops displaying past 5,000/month) and a scope limited to consent: no DSR automation, no data mapping. PieEye covers consent without that cliff, then adds automated DSR fulfillment across 500+ eCommerce connectors and data mapping — built for Shopify and BigCommerce specifically.
| Feature | PieEye | CookieYes |
|---|---|---|
| Consent management & banner | ✓ Geo-targeted, free tier available | ✓ Branding removal requires $55/mo Ultimate |
| Free plan pageview limit | No pageview cliff on the free tier | 5,000/mo — banner stops displaying past that |
| DSR automation | ✓ Across 500+ third-party tools | ✗ Not offered |
| Data mapping & DPIA | ✓ Included | ✗ Not offered |
| Cookie scanning | ✓ Plus free public scanner at pii.ai/scan | 100 pages/scan (Free) up to 8,000 (Ultimate) |
| eCommerce integrations | 500+ (Klaviyo, Yotpo, Zendesk…) | WordPress-first; generic elsewhere |
| Shopify & BigCommerce support | ✓ Native | Works, but not eCommerce-specific |
| Third-party script blocking | ✓ Trap and Trace Shield | ✗ Not included |
| Pricing model | Free tier; paid plans quoted after a demo | Per domain: Free, $10, $25, $55/mo + overage |
| Target customer | eCommerce brands | Budget-conscious small sites, primarily WordPress |
CookieYes's free plan is capped at 5,000 monthly pageviews per domain. Once a store exceeds that — often during exactly the traffic spike a growing brand wants — the banner stops displaying entirely, verified on CookieYes's pricing page in July 2026. That's a compliance gap opening at the worst possible moment. PieEye's free tier doesn't have a pageview cliff that removes your consent banner.
CookieYes is a consent management platform, full stop: banner, cookie scanning, consent records, and a policy generator. There's no automated fulfillment of data subject requests across the tools a store actually runs on, and no data mapping. PieEye automates DSR fulfillment across 500+ commerce-stack connectors — Klaviyo, Yotpo, Zendesk, and more — and includes data mapping across your stack.
CookieYes is WordPress-first, with generic support elsewhere. PieEye is built natively for Shopify and BigCommerce, with connectors curated for the commerce stack — so DSR fulfillment actually reaches the third-party tools where customer data lives, not just your website.
Book a demo to see how PieEye handles eCommerce compliance end-to-end — from cookie consent to DSR automation across your full third-party stack.
Book a Demo